Facebook's announcement that it would create a stable coin on a block chain means more like a competitive response to WeChat and Alipay's payment services than in the crypto industry, according to the AngelList founder Naval Ravikant.
Ravikant told CoinDesk via email:
"I don't think that means much to crypto because it's not really (superbly resistant) crypto."
The immediate question for the crypto industry after the announcement of Facebook's ambitious Libra project was whether this new token will lead more users to the wider world of crypto competition or isolate them from other projects. That is to say, someone who becomes a Libra-user, be more likely to hold a Bitcoin, ether, EOS or other kryptobestillinger?
For his part, Ravikant sees a way Libra could meet a need and noticed that it could lower the cost of global payments, but he added, "I'm struggling to see why it must be on a block chain other than for PR / Marketing. "
The Asian consumer payment giants Tencent (parents of WeChat) and Alibaba Alipay) seem to agree: they say they do not follow Facebook's leadership to develop crypto price developments.
That said, most of the industry sounds positive after the news that the world's fifth largest market capitalization company, Facebook, is leading a number of financial giants (such as Visa, PayPal and Stripe) in the blockchain universe.
For example, Fred Wilson, a partner at Union Square Ventures, one of the founders of the Libra Association, wrote on his blog:
"So as we think of potential l-drivers for mainstream crypto adoption, a simple, full -collateralized, cryptocurrency used in the world's largest applications, affecting hundreds of millions or billions of consumers, is perhaps the most promising. "
In fact, others pointed to certain mechanisms by which individuals can get into cryptos in a world where Libra becomes a common way of transacting value.
"This is good news for the exchange and good news for crypto because you will have much more discovered users," Avivah Litan, an analyst at Gartner, told CoinDesk. She anticipated exchanges as an important source for achieving Libra in the early days. "So now that you sign up for Libra, you'll see more cryptos as well."
People who already have access to financial services, will be motivated to find ways to get the crypto to get better deals, Kyle Samani from Multicoin Capital told CoinDesk.
"Value paper is clear: discounts through trading as Uber and Lyft and Spotify (and many more will be announced)," said Samani CoinDesk via email. For unbanked, it is the chance to use a currency that is potentially more stable than its national currency.
Preston Byrne, a lawyer at Byrne & Storm and an early entrepreneur in the world of permissible blocks, told CoinDesk he expects Libra to be useful at a high level as long as the network is not built on walls.
"As long as it requires people who are related to the ecosystem to use things that are otherwise good for kryptokurs, it is good for cryptocurrency" says Byrne.
Joey Krug, Augur & # 39; s creator and an investment officer at Pantera Capital ̵[ads1]1; one of the industry's largest crypto investors – pointed out that the infrastructure has already committed itself to playing well with the rest of the industry. 19659002] "Weapons have stated that the underlying network will have pseudonymous addresses just like any other crypto network, meaning exchanges can list Libra, which effectively makes it a ramp for all cryptos," Krug CoinDesk said.
Byrne noted that Facebook and its affiliates could use his clout to gather out other kryptokurver, if they wanted. Arianna Simpson, founder of autonomous partners and a former Facebook employee, does not see his existential threat to Bitcoin in Libra.
"Other crypto curves – Stellar and Ripple are going to think – are much more likely to have their raison d & # 39; être in doubt," she wrote in a note to their limited partners, which was shared with CoinDesk.
In fact, bitcoin actually offered another speculation. He claimed that with interest rates on government bonds that moves as far into negative territory, the Libra-reserve be difficult to find extremely conservative investments with an upside.
"I expect the Libra Association to maintain some of its reserves in inaccurate cryptographic curves as BTC. So there is a path, even if it is not confirmed."
Big wins not always
If Facebook is able to convince the world that crypto works, then Libra must work. And that's not certain.
Næringsinnsidere were quick to remember the many technological products that were never adopted.
Having said that, it seems general answer to be excitement about Facebook and its partners to educate billion people on public-private keys, payments without intermediaries and money on the Internet.
But there were many notes of caution, especially about whether Facebook actually could lead users to use their new block chain.
Joel Monegro of Placeholder, a prominent New York City venture fund, compared it to the earliest Microsoft Network iterations, which were basically Microsoft's attempt to create its own proprietary Internet.
Monegro told CoinDesk via email:
"The weapon is to Facebook what MSN was to Microsoft. They feel the opportunity but lack the point."
Likewise, the CoinFund steering wheel founder Jake Brukhman from a list of major errors from other tech giants. Although it is generally optimistic about Libra's potential to have the entire market, Brukerhman warned that "people also tend to get excited and underestimate how difficult it is to start successful products, even as established exceptional companies."
For example, he mentioned Amazon's fire phone. In addition, Google has had a cascade of failed creations. In social media alone, it failed with Orkut, Buzz, Wave and Google Plus. Apple's self-driving car product was stillborn.
But Albert Wenger, also of Union Square Ventures, wrote on his blog about how critical a wide distribution network has been the key moments of technological expansion. He also took an example from Microsoft: the introduction of Internet Explorer (IE) to all Windows users in 1995.
IE drove tremendous adoption of the internet. But as Wenger wrote, "It's helpful to remember that Microsoft wasn't the main recipient of the web."
But is it my giant?
The 53 co-authors of "The Librarian Block Chain" Block Chain was built to offer "a new global currency – Libra coin." Currencies Are Money Consumer Application But Will Libra Be Consumer-Friendly?
William Quigley was co-founder of the company that created tether, original stablecoin, and he is now CEO of WAX, a startup organized around digital property rights. He believes Libra will save people money on almost everything they buy.
"It is probably that 1.5 percent of worldwide GDP only be eaten in currency conversions," considering Quigley. "I think that's a big part of what Facebook sees."
Others do not focus on the world's anchored financial institutions.
As Tyler Cowen, one of the world's most influential economists, wrote on his blog: "Have banks ever lost a political battle of this kind?"
If any coalition could revolutionize these channels, it could be the group of extremely strong companies Facebook has gathered. But the sheer size can pose another danger to the masses.
"It comes with the risk of centralized pain points and vulnerabilities," ConsenSys founder Joseph Lubin CoinDesk said. "Data silos allow established businesses to maintain the pricing power, and also with the risk of data breaches, privacy, and security issues – problems that many have already begun to associate with Facebook."
Maya Zehavi, a block consultant and contractor, offered similar concerns. While Facebook does not theoretically want to control Libra blockchain, previous iterations in the company have been known to get destruction on startup that builds businesses dependent on Facebook platforms. Just ask Zynga.
On this very early day, Zehavi Libra said as a "closed loop".
"If you want to make an investment or want to run a product today, you need to be able to run a node, a whole node," she said. "You need to have the infrastructure in place to be part of the network." Plus, that's the cost.
Founding members of the Libra Association have paid $ 10 million each for the privilege of running a node, although there are plans to eventually open the node membership to anyone. (Founding members also get a return on investment in the form of interest generated by the Libra Reserve's potentially large pool of coin security permits.)
Nevertheless, Quigley, the tether creator, believes that the ten years of the crypto history should be the main framework for evaluating Facebook's so far. Tuesday statement. Several people CoinDesk spoke to make a version of his same point:
"Every time a new crypto competition is created, it has been additive to the overall crypto experience."
Scale image via Shutterstock